Answer by: Roger C. Bohmrich, MW
I guess this is more of an observation than actual question...my response is that glasses certainly do make a difference, but I do not believe that you need a specific shape for every type of wine.
Having participated in more than one seminar designed to "prove" how the glass determines the taste impression, I have come away persuaded in general terms only. We can never forget how much we can be influenced by suggestion. I am convinced that the size and shape of the glass do tend to neutralize or accentuate aroma and affect where on your tongue the wine is delivered initially. But the wine then usually fills your mouth, and all your taste buds come into play (see PS below). A small round glass (the standard bar wine glass) filled full may make the wine appear to be aroma-less. The same wine in a larger bowl with some degree of taper or chimney, filled half full, now reveals a definite aroma. I'm not sure I would take it much further than that, other than enjoying the look of many attractive glasses on the dinner table (I often use multiple shapes at home).
PS. Are you familiar with the "tongue map" which claims that we all taste acidity, sweetness, saltiness or bitterness in the same places on our tongue? Many glassware companies refer to it as the "scientific" basis for glass shape, at least in part. One problem: this map has been disproven, and the locations of our taste buds are not identical. What a surprise!
About the Expert:Roger has enjoyed a lengthy career in the wine trade, and he last served as a senior executive with a major national importer. In 2006, he launched Millesima USA, a retail entity affiliated with Europe's leading fine wine mail order company. Roger became one of America's first Masters of Wine in 1993, and he has been very active as an educator and speaker at wine festivals and conferences. He hosts a community television program entitled "Wine's Simple Pleasures," and is currently working on a book of original recipes and wine pairing solutions. Visit Roger C. Bohmrich, MW's website: MILLESIMA USA LLC
|